Have you tried Cookie Butter or Kerfluffle? Cookie butter was originally only available at Trader Joes, but I've found Bischoff brand at Target made from ground up cookies, which I put on graham crackers or nilla wafers for DS. Kefluffle is peanut butter made in small batches in Oregon and I've found it on Direct Eats dot come. They have peanut butter marshmallow and a smore version with chocolate. Soooo yummy.
I will have to look for those! I'm near target a lot. I'll stop in next time and try to find it! Sounds like something I might like Thanks for the suggestion.